Cross-Border Cooperation Against the Odds?

Russian and Norwegian Grassroots Organizations in a Changed Geopolitical Environment

Authors

  • Jørn Holm-Hansen
  • Aadne Aasland

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.36368/jns.v16i1.580

Keywords:

Barents Euro-Arctic Region, Arctic, cross-border, Russia, Norway

Abstract

What impact did changes in the geopolitical environment have on grassroots cross-border cooperation within the Barents Euro-Arctic Region in the years before Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022? Drawing on interviews, surveys and document studies from two evaluations made in 2007 and 2020 of the Norwegian Barents Secretariat’s grant programme, conducted by the authors of the present article, we analyse the development over time of cross-border cooperation in Russia’s northwestern and Norway’s northernmost regions. The context in which the programme was conducted in 2020 differed significantly from that in 2007. The period was one of increasingly strained relations between Russia and the West. In particular, the 2014 events in Ukraine resulted in a new geopolitical environment that posed a challenge to the ideals of cross-border trust and people-to-people cooperation. Moreover, internal political developments in Russia led to more centralized power structures and control, also regarding civil society. Although we had expected these developments to have had a negative impact on the programme’s goal achievement, we find that the programme was closer to achieving several of its objectives in 2020 than in 2007. Competence transfer went both ways, both sides benefitted more equally and despite the geopolitical complications, the number of groups involved on both sides of the border did not decrease. The article identifies the main challenges between partners, and how they were overcome.

References

Åtland, K. & Kabanenko, I. (2020). “Russia and its Western neighbours. A comparative study of the security situation in the Black, Baltic and Barents Sea regions,” Europe-Asia Studies, 72:2, pp. 286–313.

Barents Summit (2013). “Declaration on the 20th anniversary of the Barents Euro-Arctic cooperation (Kirkenes, Norway, 3–4 June 2013)”; https://www.regjeringen.no/globalassets/upload/ud/vedlegg/nordomrc3a5dene/barentssamarbeidet/barentssummitdeclaration2013.pdf; accessed on 8 March 2023.

Barentssekretariatet (2022). “Våre nye retningslinjer og vilkår for tilskudd fra Barentssekretariatet, revidert april 2022” [‘Our new guidelines and conditions for grants from the Barents Secretariat, revised April 2022’]; https://barents.no/nb/barentssekretariatet-endrer-kravene-til-prosjekter; accessed on 8 March 2023

Bar Tal, D. & Teichman, Y. (2005). Stereotypes and Prejudice in Conflict. Representations of Arabs in Israeli Jewish Society, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Berg-Nordlie, M. (2015). “Two centuries of Russian Sámi Policy. Arrangements for autonomy and participation seen in light of imperial, Soviet and federal indigenous minority policy 1822–2014,” Acta Borealia, 32:1, pp. 40–67.

Bogdanova, E. (2017). “NGOs under state regulation. Strengths and weaknesses of Russian civil society,” Laboratorium, 9:3, pp. 5–10.

Browning, C.S. (2003). “The region-building approach revisited. The continued othering of Russia in discourses of region-building in the European North,” Geopolitics, 8:1, pp. 45–71.

Brunet-Jailly, E. (2011). “Special section. Borders, borderlands and theory. An introduction,” Geopolitics, 16:1, pp. 1–6

Dellenbrant, J.Å., & Olsson, M.-O. (1994). “Regionalization and security in the European north,” in The Barents Region. Security and Economic Development in the European North, eds. J.Å. Dellenbrant, & M.-O. Olsson, Umeå: Cerum, pp. 9–17.

Eriksson, J. (1995). “Security in the Barents Region. Interpretations and implications of the Norwegian Barents initiative,” Cooperation and Conflict, 30:3, pp. 259–286

Goldin, V. (2015). “Barentssamarbeidet” [‘The Barents cooperation’], in Naboer i frykt og forventning [‘Neighbours in fear and expectation’], ed. S. Holtsmark, Oslo: Pax Forlag, pp. 615–627.

Gorbachev, M. (1987). “The speech in Murmansk at the ceremonial meeting on the occasion of the presentation of the Order of Lenin and the Gold Star Medal to the city of Murmansk, October 1, 1987,” Moscow: Novosti Press Agency, pp. 23–31; https://www.barentsinfo.fi/docs/Gorbachev_speech.pdf; accessed on 8 March 2023.

Herzog, S. & Hai, A. (2005). The Power of Possibility. The Role of People-to-People Programs in the Current Israeli–Palestinian Reality, Herzliya : Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung.

Hoffman, S. (1966). ‘‘Obstinate or obsolete. The fate of the nation state and the case of Western Europe,” Daedalus, 95:3, pp. 862–915.

Holm-Hansen, J. (2023). “Norsk russlandspolitikk under Søreide” [‘Norway’s Russia policy under Søreide’], Internasjonal Politikk, 81:1, pp. 49–59.

Holm-Hansen, J., Aasland, Aa. & Dybstyna, E. (2008). Building Neighbourhood Evaluation of the NBS’s Grant Programme, Oslo: NIBR; https://oda.oslomet.no/oda-xmlui/bitstream/handle/20.500.12199/5655/2008-4.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=; accessed on 10 Aug. 2023.

Holm-Hansen, J., Aasland, Aa. & Dybstyna, E. (2020). Still Building Neighbourhood. Mid-term Evaluation of the Norwegian NBS’s Grant Programme, Oslo: OsloMet; https://oda.oslomet.no/oda-xmlui/bitstream/handle/20.500.12199/6465/2020-24.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=; accessed on 10 Aug. 2023.

Holst, J.J. (1994). “The Barents Region institutions, cooperations and prospects,” in The Barents Region. Cooperation in Arctic Europe, eds. O.S. Stokke & O. Tunander, London: Sage Publications, pp. 11–24.

Hønneland, G. (1998). “Identity formation in the Barents Euro-Arctic Region,” Cooperation and Conflict, 33:3, pp.277–297.

Hønneland, G. (2010). “East-West collaboration in the European North. Structures and perceptions,” International Journal. Canada’s Journal of Global Policy Analysis, 65:4, pp. 837–850.

Hønneland, G. (2017). Arctic Euphoria and International High North Politics, London: Palgrave

Jonassen, T. (2022). “Grenseboerbeviset ti år: – Vi har ingenting å feire” [‘The local border traffic permit is ten years old: – No reason to celebrate’], High North News 13 April; https://www.highnorthnews.com/nb/grenseboerbeviset-ti-ar-vi-har-ingenting-feire; accessed on 5 March 2023.

Klatt, M. & Wassenberg, B. (2017). “Secondary foreign policy. Can local and regional cross-border cooperation function as a tool for peace-building and reconciliation?” Regional & Federal Studies, 27:3, pp. 205–218.

Kortukov, D. (2020). “‘Sovereign Democracy’ and the politics of ideology in Putin’s Russia,” Russian Politics, 5:1, pp. 81–104

Landriault, M., Payette, J.-F. & Roussel, S. (2021). “Introduction,” in Mapping Arctic Paradiplomacy. Limits and Opportunities for Sub-National Actors in Arctic Governance, eds. M. Landriault, J.-F. Payette & S. Roussel, London: Routledge, pp. 1–16.

Laruelle, M. (2020). “Making sense of Russia’s illiberalism,” Journal of Democracy, 31:3, pp. 115–129.

Lewis, D.G. (2020). Russia’s New Authoritarianism. Putin and the Politics of Order, Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.

Loughlin, J. (2019). “Regions in Europe and Europe of the regions. The origins of Regional and Federal Studies,” Regional and Federal Studies, 31:1, pp. 25–30.

Mikhailova, E. (2016). “Endogennye problemy prigranichnogo sotrudnichestva ‘gorodov-bliznetsov’” [‘Endogenous challenges for cross-border cooperation between “twin-cities”’], Regional’nye issledovaniya, 3:53, pp. 109–117.

Neumann, I.B. (1994). “A region-building approach to Northern Europe,” Review of International Studies, 20:1, pp. 53–74.

Østhagen, A. (2020). “The good, the bad and the ugly. Three levels of Arctic geopolitics,” in The Arctic and World Order, eds. K. Spohr & D.S. Hamilton, Brookings Institution Press: Washington, D.C., pp. 357–378

Regjeringen [‘The Government’] (2011). Meld. St. 7 (2011–2012). Nordområdene. Visjon og virkemidler [‘Report to the Parliament No 7 (2011–2012) The High North. Vision and tools’]; https://www.regjeringen.no/no/dokumenter/meld-st-7-20112012/id663433/; accessed on 8 March 2023.

Regjeringen [‘The Government’] (2020). Meld. St. 9 (2020–2021). Mennesker, muligheter og norske interesser i nord [‘Report to the Parliament No 9 (2020–2021). People, opportunities and Norwegian interests in the North’]; https://www.regjeringen.no/no/dokumenter/meld.-st.-9-20202021/id2787429/; accessed on 8 March 2023.

Robertsen, T. (2014). Banebrytende Barentssamarbeid. Fra mistro til vennskap [‘Pioneering Barents cooperation. From distrust to friendship’], Vadsø: Robertsen (published by author).

Schumacher, T. & Bouris, D. (2016). “The 2011 revised European neighbourhood policy. Continuity and change in EU foreign policy,” in The Revised European Neighbourhood Policy, eds. D. Bouris & T. Schumacher, Palgrave Macmillan, London, pp. 1–33.

Shabaev, Yu., Zherebtsov, I., Kim, H.Y. & Kim, H.T. (2016). “Pomors, Pomor’e, and the Russian North. A symbolic space in cultural and political context,” Sibirica, 15:2, pp. 73–102.

Shrestha, Ch.L. (2019). “Promoting regional people-to-people exchange and cooperation among regional thinktanks,” in China’s Belt and Road Initiative and Building The Community Of Common Destiny, eds. W. Linggui & Zh. Jianglin Singapore: World Scientific Publishing, pp. 143–152.

Stokke, O.S. (2015). “Institutional complexity in Arctic governance—curse or blessing?” in Handbook of the Politics of the Arctic, eds. L. C. Jensen & G. Hønneland, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 328–351.

Strang, J. (2016). Nordic Political and Economic Cooperation. Context, History and Outlook, Forum Paper (AEMI), Asean Studies Centre; https://www.asean-aemi.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/AEMI-Forum-November-2015-Strang-Feb2016.pdf; accessed on 9 March 2023

Tulaeva, S., Tysiachniuk, M. & Henry, L. (2017). “Strategies of environmental NGOs in the context of the law on foreign agents. Games with formality,” Laboratorium, 9:3, pp. 18–43.

van Houtum, H. (2000). “III European perspectives on borderlands. An overview of European geographical research on borders and border regions,” Journal of Borderland Studies, 15:1, pp. 56–83.

Zmyvalova, E. (2020). “Human rights of indigenous small-numbered peoples in Russia. Recent developments,” Arctic Review on Law and Politics, 11, pp. 334–359.

Zysk, K. (2015). “Forsvars- og sikkerhetspolitikken. Nye muligheter, ny usikkerhet” [‘Defense and security policies. New opportunities, new insecurity’], in Naboer i frykt og forventning [‘Neighbours in fear and expectation’], ed. S. Holtsmark, Oslo: Pax Forlag, pp. 555–564

Downloads

Published

2024-03-07

Issue

Section

Articles