Knowledge Gaps about Mining Impacts on Sami Lands
A Call for Epistemic Justice in European Minerals Extraction
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.36368/jns.v17i1.1232Keywords:
green transition, epistemic justice, Indigenous, Sami, mineral extraction, environmental impact assessmentsAbstract
In the context of the EU’s Critical Raw Materials Act, which prioritizes mineral extraction and imposes time limits on project approvals, there have been a surge of policy proposals that aim to expedite licenses for green industry projects. Meanwhile, the academic literature largely overlooks risks for Indigenous Sami rights and reindeer herding. In this paper, we examine if a similar knowledge gap exists in a key part of the practitioner literature informing licensing decisions for new mines, namely environmental impact assessments (EIAs). To do so, we undertake a comparative synthesis of results from i) unpublished findings from a review of selected EIAs from mining companies in Sweden, and ii) a review of Sami knowledge about impacts at two mining sites in Sweden. Findings reveal a considerable mismatch between predicted impacts in corporate EIAs and those impacts experienced by herding communities. Using an epistemic justice lens, we argue that this knowledge gap is no coincidence—instead it reflects an epistemic injustice underlying European and hence Swedish minerals policy and its ambitions to fast-track licensing and exploit Sami lands in the name of the green transition.
References
Advisory Committee on the Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities. Fifth Opinion on Sweden; https://rm.coe.int/5th-op-sweden-en/1680ae851a; accessed on 2 March 2024.
Agrawal, A. (1995). “Dismantling the divide between indigenous and scientific knowledge,” Development and Change, 26:3, pp. 413–439.
CERD (2020). International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination. Opinion Adopted by the Committee under Article 14 of the Convention, Concerning Communication No. 54/2013*,**.
Dotson, K. (2011). “Tracking epistemic violence, tracking practices of silencing,” Hypatia, 26:2, pp. 236–257.
Fairhead, J., Leach, M. & Scoones, I. (2012). “Green grabbing. A new appropriation of nature?” The Journal of Peasant Studies, 39:2, pp. 237–261.
Fjellheim, E.M. (2023). “Wind energy on trial in Saepmie. Epistemic controversies and strategic ignorance in Norway’s green energy transition,” Arctic Review on Law and Politics, 14, pp. 140–168.
Fricker, M. (2007). Epistemic Injustice. Power and the Ethics of Knowing, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Fröberg, J. (2023). “Här ställs kampen om samebyns framtid på sin spets” [‘The battle for the future of the Sami village is coming to a head’], Dagens Nyheter 10 Dec.
Gunnarsson, J. (2017). “Vindkraftsbolagen stoppade larmrapport om rennäringen” [‘The wind power companies halted the alarm report about reindeer husbandry’], Process Nordic, 3, p. 3.
Haddaway, N.R., Cooke, S.J., Lesser, P., Macura, B., Nilsson, A.E., Taylor, J.J. & Raitio, K. (2022). “Evidence of the impacts of metal mining and the effectiveness of mining mitigation measures on social-ecological systems in Arctic and boreal regions. A systematic map,” Environmental Evidence, 8:9, pp. 1–11.
Harding, S. (1996). The Science Question in Feminism, Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Herrmann, T.M., Brunner Alfani, F., Chahine, A., Doering, N., Dudeck, S., Elster, J., Fjellheim, E., Henriksen, J.E., Hermansen, N., Holmberg, A., Kramvig, B., Keskitalo, A.M.N., Omma, E.M., Saxinger, G., Scheepstra, A. & van der Schot, J. (2023). Comprehensive Policy-Brief to the EU Commission. Roadmap to Decolonial Arctic Research, Áltá – Kárášjohka – Leipzig – Oulu.
Kejerhag, J. (2023). “LKAB:s gruvfynd kom som en chock för samebyn” [‘LKAB’s mining discovery came as a shock to the Sami reindeer herding community’], Dagens Nyheter 13 Jan.
Kemp, D. & Owen, J.R. (2024). “Researching ‘resource frontiers’ is vital for understanding the human consequences of scaling up renewable energy technologies,” One Earth, 7:2, pp. 167–170.
Kløcker Larsen, R. (2017). “Impact assessment and indigenous self-determination. A scalar framework of participation options,” Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal, 36:3, pp. 208–219.
Kløcker Larsen, R., Boström, M., Muonio Reindeer Herding District, Vilhelmina Södra Reindeer Herding District, Voernese Reindeer Herding District & Wik-Karlsson, J. (2022). “The impacts of mining on Sámi lands. A knowledge synthesis from three reindeer herding districts,” The Extractive Industries and Society, 9:101051, pp. 1–10; doi.org/10.1016/j.exis.2022.101051.
Knobblock, I. (2021). “Att skriva från gränslandet. Dekoloniala berättelser från Sábme” [‘Writing from the borderlands. Decolonial stories from Sápmi’], Kulturella Perspektiv. Svensk etnologisk tidskrift, 30, pp. 1–7.
Kuokkanen, R. (2023). “Is reindeer the new buffalo? Climate change, the green shift and manifest destiny in Sápmi,” Meridians, 22:1, pp. 11–33.
Laframboise, L. (2022). “Brussels looks north. The European Union’s latest Arctic policy and the potential for ‘green’ colonialism,” The Arctic Institute—Center for Circumpolar Security Studies, 20 Sept.; www.thearcticinstitute.org/brussels-looks-north-european-unions-latest-arctic-policy-potential-green-colonialism/; accessed on 4 Feb. 2025.
Lassila, M.M. (2023). “An irreplaceable place. Onto-epistemological contestation in the environmental impact assessment process of the green Anglo American Sakatti mine, Arctic Finland,” Society & Natural Resources, 37:5, pp. 623–643.
Lawrence, R. & Åhren, M. (2016). “Mining as colonisation. The need for restorative justice and restitution of traditional Sami lands,” in Nature, Temporality and Environmental Management. Scandinavian and Australian Perspectives on Peoples and Landscapes, eds. L. Head, K. Saltzman, G. Setten & M. Stenseke, Abingdon, Oxon: Routledge, pp. 149–166.
Lawrence, R. & Raitio, K. (2016). “Academia and activism in Saami research. Negotiating the blurred spaces between,” in Ethics in Indigenous Research Past Experiences. Future Challenges, ed. A.-L. Drugge (Sámi Dutkan—Samiska Studier—Sami Studies 7), Umeå: Vaartoe—Centre for Sami Research, pp. 117–136.
Lewis, J., Hoover, J. & MacKenzie, D. (2017). “Mining and environmental health disparities in Native American communities,” Current Environmental Health Reports, 4:2, pp. 130–141.
LKAB (2023). Europe’s Largest Deposit of Rare Earth Elements 25 Percent Larger. Today Marks First Step in Critical Review; https://lkab.com/en/press/europes-largest-deposit-of-rare-earth-elements-now-25-percent-larger-today-marks-the-first-step-in-critical-review/; accessed 26 Feb. 2024.
Macura, B., Haddaway, N.R., Lesser, P. & Nilsson, A.E. (2019). “Mapping the predicted and potential impacts of metal mining and its mitigation measures in Arctic and boreal regions using environmental and social impact assessments. A systematic map protocol,” Environmental Evidence, 8:21, pp. 1–6.
Nilsson, R. (2021). Att bearkadidh. Om samiskt självbestämmande och samisk självkonstituering [‘Bearkadidh. On Sami self-determination and Sami self-constitution’] (Stockholm Studies in Politics 194), diss., Stockholm: Stockholm University.
Normann, S. (2020). “Green colonialism in the Nordic context. Exploring Southern Saami representations of wind energy development,” Journal of Community Psychology, 49:1, pp. 77–94.
O’Faircheallaigh, C. (2023). Indigenous Peoples and Mining. A Global Perspective, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Össbo, Å. (2023). “Back to square one. Green sacrifice zones in Sápmi and Swedish policy responses to energy emergencies,” Arctic Review on Law and Politics, 14, pp. 112–134.
Raitio, K., Allard, C. & Lawrence, R. (2020). “Mineral extraction in Swedish Sápmi. The regulatory gap between Sami rights and Sweden’s mining permitting practices,” Land Use Policy, 99:105001, pp. 1–15; doi. org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2020.105001.
Raitio, K. & Kløcker Larsen, R. (2023). “EU’s Critical Raw Materials Act fails to protect Sámi rights. Here’s how to strengthen it,” Euractiv 10 Nov.
Regulation (EU) 2024/1252 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 April 2024 establishing a framework for ensuring a secure and sustainable supply of critical raw materials and amending Regulations (EU) No 168/2013, (EU) 2018/858, (EU) 2018/1724 and (EU) 2019/1020 (Text with EEA relevance) (2024); https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2024/1252/oj/eng; accessed on 4 Feb. 2025.
Roche, C., Brueckner, M. & Walim, N. (2021). “Understanding why impact assessment fails. A case study of theory and practice from Wafi-Golpu, Papua New Guinea,” Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 89:106582, pp. 1–12; doi.org/10.1016/j.eiar.2021.106582.
Schipper, E.L.F., Ensor, J., Mukherji, A., Mirzabaev, A., Fraser, A., Harvey, B., Totin, E., Garschagen, M., Pathak, M., Antwi-Agyei, P., Tanner, T. & Shawoo, Z. (2021). “Equity in climate scholarship. A manifesto for action,” Climate and Development, 13:10, pp. 853–856.
Sultana, F. (2022). “The unbearable heaviness of climate coloniality,” Political Geography, 99:102638, pp. 1–14; doi.org/10.1016/j.polgeo.2022.102638.
“Sveriges första nya gruva på tio år öppnas i Vindelgransele. ‘Finns guld för en miljard i området’” [‘Sweden’s first mine in ten years. “Gold worth a million in the area”’], unsigned article in SVT Nyheter 25 April 2024.
Tolvanen, A., Eilu, P., Juutinen, A., Kangas, K., Kivinen, M., Markovaara-Koivisto, M., Naskali, A., Salokannel, V., Tuulentie, A. & Similä, J. (2019). “Mining in the Arctic environment. A review from ecological, socioeconomic and legal perspectives,” Journal of Environmental Management, 233, pp. 832–844.
Tornel, C. (2023). “Energy justice in the context of green extractivism. Perpetuating ontological and epistemological violence in the Yucatan Peninsula,” Journal of Political Ecology, 30:1, pp. 846–873.
Zachrisson, A. & Beland Lindahl, K. (2019). “Political opportunity and mobilization. The evolution of a Swedish mining-sceptical movement,” Resources Policy, 64:101477, pp. 1–12; doi.org/10.1016/j.resourpol. 2019.101477.
Zografos, C. & Robbins, P. (2020). “Green sacrifice zones, or why a green new deal cannot ignore the cost shifts of just transitions,” One Earth, 3:5, pp. 543–546.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Laura Del Duca, Adriana Abril, Rasmus Kløcker Larsen, Biljana Macura, Neal R. Haddaway, Maria Boström
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
