The challenges of health reform in Senegal: qualitative analysis of the departmentalization of health mutuals
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
Introduction: In Senegal, community-based health insurance (CBHI) schemes have long been favoured as the main instrument for achieving universal health coverage (UHC). Historically managed by community volunteers, these schemes have struggled with financial sustainability and coverage effectiveness. In response, Senegal launched a reform in 2022, transitioning from communal to departmental CBHI schemes to enhance management and service delivery. This study aims to explore the challenges associated with implementing this reform in the country.
Methods: The qualitative study was conducted from 2020 to 2023, utilizing 27 in-depth interviews with stakeholders from four regions to explore the roles of social actors, ideas, power dynamics, and context in the reform. The interviews specifically aimed to capture the dynamics of support and resistance to the transition from communal to departmental CBHI. Data were analyzed using a thematic analysis approach.
Results: Findings reveal significant resistance among existing communal CBHI managers who fear loss of autonomy and financial control. Stakeholders expressed concerns over the rapid and top-down approach of the reform process, which many felt was forced upon them without adequate consultation. Despite these challenges, some stakeholders recognized the potential benefits of professional management and streamlined operations to enhance healthcare accessibility and efficiency.
Conclusion: The study shows that despite encountering resistance stemming from entrenched ideas, values, and power dynamics, the reform has been accepted and is currently being implemented. The role that departmental CBHI will play in the ongoing reform process remains to be seen.
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Authors of content published in JCSH retain the copyright to their works.
References
Michielsen J, Verstraeten B, Vervoort F, Criel B. Community Health Insurance in Low- and Middle-Income Countries. In: International Encyclopedia of Public Health. Elsevier; 2025. p. 374–89. Available from: https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/B9780323999670001903.
Waelkens MP, Soors W, Criel B. Community Health Insurance in Low- and Middle-Income Countries. In: International Encyclopedia of Public Health. Elsevier; 2017. p. 82–92. Available from: https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/B9780128036785000825.
Eze P, Ilechukwu S, Lawani LO. Impact of community-based health insurance in low- and middle-income countries: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Vojnov L, editor. PLoS One. 2023 Jun 27;18(6):e0287600.
Ly MS, Bassoum O, Faye A. Universal health insurance in Africa: a narrative review of the literature on institutional models. BMJ Glob Health. 2022 Apr;7(4):e008219.
Daff BM, Diouf S, Diop ESM, Mano Y, Nakamura R, Sy MM, et al. Reforms for financial protection schemes towards universal health coverage, Senegal. Bull World Health Organ. 2020 Feb 1;98(2):100–8.
Alenda-Demoutiez J, Boidin B. Community-based mutual health organisations in Senegal: a specific form of social and solidarity economy? Review of Social Economy. 2019 Oct 2;77(4):417–41.
Ly MS, Faye A, Ba MF. Impact of community-based health insurance on healthcare utilisation and out-of-pocket expenditures for the poor in Senegal. BMJ Open. 2022 Dec;12(12):e063035.
Adebayo EF, Uthman OA, Wiysonge CS, Stern EA, Lamont KT, Ataguba JE. A systematic review of factors that affect uptake of community-based health insurance in low-income and middle-income countries. BMC Health Serv Res. 2015 Jun;15(1):543.
Agyepong IA, Abankwah DNY, Abroso A, Chun C, Dodoo JNO, Lee S, et al. The “Universal” in UHC and Ghana’s National Health Insurance Scheme: policy and implementation challenges and dilemmas of a lower middle income country. BMC Health Serv Res. 2016 Dec;16(1).
Conde KK, Camara AM, Jallal M, Khalis M, Zbiri S, De Brouwere V. Factors determining membership in community-based health insurance in West Africa: a scoping review. Glob Health Res Policy. 2022 Nov 28;7(1):46.
Dror DM, Hossain SAS, Majumdar A, Pérez Koehlmoos TL, John D, Panda PK. What factors affect voluntary uptake of community-based health insurance schemes in low- and middle-income countries? A systematic review and meta-analysis. Weary D, editor. PLoS One. 2016 Aug 31;11(8):e0160479.
Mladovsky P, Ndiaye P, Ndiaye A, Criel B. The impact of stakeholder values and power relations on community-based health insurance coverage: qualitative evidence from three Senegalese case studies. Health Policy Plan. 2015 Jul 1;30(6):768–81.
N’diaye P. Le développement des mutuelles de santé en Afrique. In: Dussault G, Fournier P, Letourmy A, editors. L’assurance maladie en afrique francophone: améliorer l’accès aux soins et lutter contre la pauvreté. Washington,DC: Banque Mondiale; 2006. p. 311–30.
Rouyard T, Mano Y, Daff BM, Diouf S, Fall Dia K, Duval L, et al. Operational and structural factors influencing enrolment in community-based health insurance schemes: an observational study using 12 waves of nationwide panel data from Senegal. Health Policy Plan. 2022 Aug 3;37(7):858–71.
Waelkens MP, Coppieters Y, Laokri S, Criel B. An in-depth investigation of the causes of persistent low membership of community-based health insurance: a case study of the mutual health organisation of Dar Naïm, Mauritania. BMC Health Serv Res. 2017 Dec;17(1).
Hsiao WC, Yip W. Financing and provision of healthcare for two billion people in low-income nations: Is the cooperative healthcare model a solution? Soc Sci Med. 2024 Mar;345:115730.
Gilson L, Mills A. Health sector reform in sub-Saharan Africa: Lesson of the last 10 years. In: Berman P, editor. Health sector reform in developing countries, Making Health development sustainable. Boston: Harvard University Press; 1995. p. 277–316.
Mbow NB, Senghor I, Ridde V. The resilience of two professionalized departmental health insurance units during the COVID-19 pandemic in Senegal. J Glob Health. 2020;10(2):1–6.
Roberts MJ, editor. Getting health reform right: a guide to improving performance and equity. Oxford; New York: Oxford University Press; 2004. 332 p.
Mathauer I, Vinyals Torres L, Kutzin J, Jakab M, Hanson K. Pooling financial resources for universal health coverage: options for reform. Bull World Health Organ. 2020 Feb 1;98(2):132–9.
Touré L, Boivin P, Diarra Y, Diabaté S, Ridde, V. Innovations in mutuality: challenges and learnings for the Universal Health Insurance Plan in Mali. BMJ Glob Health. 2023;7(Suppl 9):e011055.
Tong A, Sainsbury P, Craig J. Consolidated criteria for reporting qualitative research (COREQ): a 32-item checklist for interviews and focus groups. Int J Qual Health Care. 2007 Sep 16;19(6):349–57.
Durand F, Ridde V, Touré L, Coulibaly A. The moderating role of support for innovation in sub-Saharan African healthcare teams: a multilevel perspective. Curr Psychol. 2023 Feb 23;43:1446–56.
Gilson L. Trust and the development of health care as a social institution. Soc Sci Med. 2003 Apr;56(7):1453–68.
Whyle E, Olivier J. Social values and health systems in health policy and systems research: a mixed-method systematic review and evidence map. Health Policy Plan. 2020 Jul 1;35(6):735–51.
Gilson L, editor. Health Policy and Systems research. A methodology reader. Geneva: Alliance for Health Policy and Systems Research, World Health Organization; 2012. 472 p.
Crozier M, Friedberg E. Actors and systems: the politics of collective action. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 1980. 333 p.
Reich MR, Campos PA. A Guide to Applied Political Analysis for Health Reform. India Health Systems Project Working Paper No. 1; 2020 p. 23. Available from: https://cdn1.sph.harvard.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/2216/2020/08/Guide-Applied-Political-Analysis-final-2020.08.29-FINAL.pdf.
Ridde V, Caffin JH, Hane F. External influences over Senegalese health financing policy: delaying universal health coverage? Health Policy Plan. 2024;39(1):80–3.
Caffin JH. L’aide au développement et le financement basé sur la performance: quelle performativité ? [Doctorat ès sciences de gestion]. [Paris]: Ecole Doctorale de Management Panthéon-Sorbonne; 2018.
Patton MQ. Sampling, Qualitative (Purposeful). In: Ritzer G, editor. The Blackwell Encyclopedia of Sociology. John Wiley&Sons. 2015. Available from: 10.1002/9781405165518.wbeoss012.pub2
Alenda-Demoutiez J. Les mutuelles de santé au Sénégal face aux difficultés de coordination de leurs acteurs. Revue internationale de l’économie sociale. 2017;(345):69.
Diop MA. « Encore un luxe ! ». L’assurance volontaire chez les travailleurs précaires à l’ère de la couverture maladie universelle au Sénégal. Émulations. 2019 Dec 15.
Mladovsky P. Fragmentation by design: Universal health coverage policies as governmentality in Senegal. Soc Sci Med. 2020 Sep;260:113153.
Paul E, Ndiaye Y, Sall FL, Fecher F, Porignon D. An assessment of the core capacities of the Senegalese health system to deliver Universal Health Coverage. Health Policy Open. 2020 Dec;1:100012.
Michielsen J, Criel B. Can community health insurance really live up to the expectations of providing equitable healthcare of sound quality? Soc Sci Med. 2024 Mar;345:115741.
McIntyre D, Garshong B, Mtei G, Meheus F, Thiede M, Akazili J, et al. Beyond fragmentation and towards universal coverage: insights from Ghana, South Africa and the United Republic of Tanzania. Bull World Health Organ. 2008 Nov;86(11):871–6.
Mbengue Wade Z, Ndoye A, Dieng M. Audit de performance. Volet développement des mutuelles de santé/ Programme de la couverture maladie universelle. Gestions 2015-2019. Dakar: Cour des comptes. Chambre des affaires administratives.; 2021 p. 116.
CESPPP. Evaluation de la politique nationale de santé et du système de santé. Dakar: Commission d’évaluation et de suivi des politiques et programmes publics; 2023 p. 382.
Wood A. Invoking Senghor. Universal healthcare coverage and the place of culture in Senegal. Med Anthropol Theory. 2024;11(2):1–8.
Alemu G, Shigute Z, Mebratie A, Sparrow R, Bedi AS. On the functioning of community-based health insurance schemes in rural Ethiopia. Soc Sci Med. 2023 Jan;115739.
Schneider P. A commentary to: “Is the cooperative healthcare model a solution for 2 billion low-income people?” Soc Sci Med. 2024 Mar;345:115740.
Quintana AV, Mayhew SH, Kovats S, Gilson L. A story of (in)coherence: climate adaptation for health in South African policies. Health Policy Plan. 2024 Apr 10;39(4):400–11.
Olivier de Sardan JP, Diarra A, Moha M. Travelling models and the challenge of pragmatic contexts and practical norms: the case of maternal health. Health Res Policy Syst. 2017;15(S1).
Béland D, Foli R, Haang’andu P. Scales of ideational policy influence: A multi-level, actor-centric, and institutionalist perspective on the role of ideas in African social policy. J Int Comp Soc Policy. 2024;39(3):264–77.
Ridde V, Kane B, Mbow NB, Senghor I, Faye A. The sustainability of two departmental health insurance units in Senegal: A qualitative study. SSM - Health Syst. 2024 Jun;2:100006.
Béland D, Ridde V. Ideas and Policy Implementation: Understanding the Resistance against Free Health Care in Africa. Glob Health Gov. 2016;10(3):9–23.
Goita SO. Les difficultés de mise en place de l’assurance maladie obligatoire au Mali: le cas des enseignants du supérieur. Revue française des affaires sociales. 2018;(1):199–204.
Dufour Y, Lamothe L. Les approches au changement dans les systèmes de santé. In: Bégin C, Bergeron P, Forest PG, Lemieux V, editors. Le système de santé québécois, Un modèle en transformation. Montréal: Presses de l’Université de Montréal; 1999. p. 313–39.
Ridde V, Faye A. Policy response to COVID-19 in Senegal: power, politics, and the choice of policy instruments. Policy Des Pract. 2022;1–20.
Da Silva N. La bataille de la Sécu: Une histoire du système de santé. Paris: La Fabrique Editions; 2022.
Shriwise A, Schmitt C. Understanding the origins of social policy in colonial contexts: An actor-centric approach. J Int Comp Soc Policy. 2023 Nov;39(3):247–63.
Agyepong IA, Adjei S. Public social policy development and implementation: a case study of the Ghana National Health Insurance scheme. Health Policy Plan. 2007 Nov 12;23(2):150–60.
Atim C. Personal communication. 2024.
Coenegrachts M. Évaluation intermédiaire. SEN/031 Programme Santé et protection sociale du quatrième Programme indicatif de coopération. Dakar: Particip GmbH et LuxDev; 2022 p. 7.
Bonoli G. Political Institutions, Veto Points, and the Process of Welfare State Adaptation. In: Pierson P, editor. The New Politics of the Welfare State. 1st ed. Oxford University PressOxford; 2001. p. 238–64. Available from: https://academic.oup.com/book/25843/chapter/193505404.
Ridde V, Olivier de Sardan JP. The development world: conflicts of interest at all levels. Rev Int Ètudes Dév. 2022 Sep 29;(249):247–69.
Sabatier PA, Weible CM, editors. Theories of the policy process. Third edition. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, a member of the Persus Books Group; 2014. 423 p.
Wood A. Patronage, partnership, voluntarism: Community-based health insurance and the improvisation of universal health coverage in Senegal. Soc Sci Med. 2023 Feb;319:115491.